Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Now obviously the new PM and his buddies (I've seen this before) only make everything worse. "Jira" or "Scrum" or "Agile" wasn't really appreciated by the old team used to doing whatever they wanted to do.

Everything I have read about agile is that if you do it right, everyone is happy. The customer, the developers, and the managers. Agile itself is supposed to be development-centric.

Tonight, I realized that Agile does not handle politics very well. I mean, how can it? It's just a software development methodology.



> Everything I have read about agile is that if you do it right, everyone is happy. The customer, the developers, and the managers.

So they said about all its predecessors, as well. Pretty soon, they start adding "...of course, you must have exceptionally competent people", and then they define 'doing it right' by 'having a successful outcome'.

Problem solved by begging the question.


Take a read at the Agile Manifesto, and I doubt you'll find any point there to criticize.

But then, take a look at any agile methodology, and try to explain how it fits the manifesto. Or better, explain how adopting any "agile methodology" fits the manifesto by itself.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: