Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Your link for Kyklos doesn't match up with your summary. Polybdius's description cited on Wikipedia suggests that the cycle is Anarchy -> Monarchy -> Tyranny -> Aristocracy -> Oligarchy -> Democracy -> Anarchy, with each pair forming a basic government + degenerate form of that government and the cycle trending towards greater dispersal of power, until the final degenerate form of democracy (anarchy/mob rule) fails to provide a society at all and a new strong-man emerges to rule it.

The Strauss-Howe cycle has a very different mechanism; in particular, the time scales are much shorter (80 years vs. several generations), and the mechanism proposed is each generation's individual childhood/formative experiences rather than interactions & social cohesion between individuals.




This is verbatim from the wiki summary:

"According to Polybius, who has the most fully developed version of the cycle, it rotates through the three basic forms of government, democracy, aristocracy, and monarchy"

The version you describe is the Anacyclosis, which is equally valid IMO but not what I linked.


That full paragraph:

"According to Polybius, who has the most fully developed version of the cycle, it rotates through the three basic forms of government, democracy, aristocracy, and monarchy and the three degenerate forms of each of these governments ochlocracy, oligarchy, and tyranny. Originally society is in anarchy but the strongest figure emerges and sets up a monarchy. The monarch's descendants, who because of their family's power lack virtue, become despots and the monarchy degenerates into a tyranny. Because of the excesses of the ruler the tyranny is overthrown by the leading citizens of the state who set up an aristocracy. They too quickly forget about virtue and the state becomes an oligarchy. These oligarchs are overthrown by the people who set up a democracy. Democracy soon becomes corrupt and degenerates into mob rule, beginning the cycle anew."




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: