Shameless plug: We just launched an affordable PCB prototyping service in Europe with native KiCad support. The PCBs are manufactured in Germany with a manufacturer usually working for the automotive and medical industry. See https://go.aisler.net for details.
What are the benefits of accepting kicad files instead of gerbers?
I understand people can make errors when generating gerbers but they can also make tons of errors when sending you the kicad files (like not including custom libraries).
KiCad Pcbnew files contain all required footprints etc., unlike the schematic files you need no libraries or such.
Creating Gerber files is sometimes hard as different fabs require different Gerber files. Starting with the file extension ending with floating point precision.
One argument against uploading KiCad files is copyright as the fab could reverse engineer the PCB. But this does not count for open source projects and is really unlikely to happen.
All these PCB manufacturers are super cool, but does anyone know any services which come closer to making complete products for you based on design files?
I'm thinking about flashing microcontrollers, soldering components, inserting PCBs I to cases, putting them into packaging?
Obviously the holy grail would be for them to do everything in small batch runs and handle shipping for you too, but I'm also interested in services which may do only parts of this.
"Once you receive your PCBs, you can simply use some solder paste and a hot air rework station to put everything together!" Right. Soldering SMT parts is not easy and takes practice. You need to practice on junk or practice boards (there are $3 kits for this) to get the technique.
Here's somebody who's good at it doing it.[1]
I sometimes do this stuff, but the magnifier and tweezers thing is hard work.
The pros all use lead-free solder now, but most hobbyists are still using leaded solder, which is much more tolerant of temperature variations.
Honestly though, SMD is not that difficult once you learn the technique. If you can handle screen-printing a t-shirt, you can handle the hardest part of doing SMD properly: using a mask/screen to deposit solder paste onto the PCB is just as simple as a screen-print for t-shirts, and once that is done its just a matter of having a patient hand for parts placement, stick it in the oven, and off you go .. a lot easier than you might think, at first.
If you have a stencil printer, yes. Simple SMT stencil printers for unframed stencils are unreasonably expensive.[1][2]
I'd been using TechShop's SMT equipment, which is junk.
It's getting better since I got a Puhui T-962 oven with all the mods to make it sort of work. I've gone lead-free, which makes it tougher. But I keep getting solder bridges between pins.
Eh, the 0805 passives he's using and the relatively coarse-pitched package on the Atmega32U4 shouldn't be too bad. This seems like a fairly reasonable project to learn SMT soldering with.
Not sure about his paranoia over the crystal routing - it's an Atmega, the crystal is 16 MHz. Anyway, I think this is more of a KiCAD tutorial than a keyboard design tutorial (not something particularly high on my list of designs I'd like to do).
I keep trying KiCAD but with a paid alternative (Altium Designer) through work it doesn't compare. The key to electronics design is the library. There are a few alternatives which are tied to vendors, like DigiKey's Schemeit. They have decent libraries of parts. I would have figured that KiCAD would too, but the last time I tried it was pretty bad. Hope that's changed.
The crystal routing is pretty critical (and personally, I think the layout detailed here is not optimal either) --- it's a low-amplitude, high frequency signal, and getting it marginal means the oscillator might not always start up reliably..
To be honest, I don't think it so much of an issue any more. I have a library of parts I use regularly and just design footprints for new parts.
I'm my case, I doubt that Altium would have footprints for many of the parts I want to use anyway (quite often cheap connectors, switches etc). I feel like being comfortable with footprint design is an important part of the design process.
That said, there are many features of Altium that look very attractive. For example the push and shove routing.
kicad libraries are open source and maintained by the community. they are generally okay but if you don't like them feel free to contribute with better ones:
