Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

(possibly misinterpreted) medical research is on par with PR fluff/astroturfing, huh?


Yes and no. Not all medical research is created equal. The tobacco industry has done a lot of "research" that's not scientifically honest. Google news used to be my home page and once a week in the health section there was an article about coffee. My mom is a coffee junkie and she always talks about the latest coffee health story in the washington post. I'm not levying a formal accusation of foul play, I'm just saying that coffee articles get a disproportionate amount of play for their importance in human health.


(1) Because of how much money coffee generates for its producers and (especially) retailers, I’d guess there are a lot of industry funds being slushed around for research and PR.

(2) Even so, it would be possible to account for far more articles about coffee than would be “proportional” to the magnitude of its health effects, simply because of how wildly popular it is, and its role as a modern ‘social icon’ of sorts.

Put (1) and (2) together and you get the media equivalent of a caffeine addiction.


Right on. Combine that with an ambient fear that coffee is bad for you and we may have an explanation.


My gut tells me this whole caffeine craze is going to be a major health concern in 10-20 years. The amount of caffeine people consume versus 20 years ago is absolutely insane.

I used to drink the equivalent of 12 shots of espresso a day. In fact, I could rock out a cup of nasty NYC bodega sludge and fall asleep 20 minutes later. Now I can't drink it at all lest I have a panic attack, save a small decaf in the morning to fool my brain.

Caffeinism, caffeine allergy and caffeine induced organic mental disorder are real things.

I also wonder if there is any causality between the decline in the number of smokers and the rise in the amount of caffeine we consume.


I also wonder if there is any causality between the decline in the number of smokers and the rise in the amount of caffeine we consume.

That wouldn't surprise me at all. The idea that people with addictions often substitute one addictive behavior for another is conventional wisdom in counseling circles, I believe.

But I'm a former cancer researcher, I know people who have drunk themselves to death, and I have friends who counsel heroin addicts. So trust me when I say this: Caffeine is an excellent alternative.

At least you were able to stop drinking caffeine, and we're pretty sure that your liver or lungs aren't going to explode in ten years from the espresso abuse.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: