Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Assuming no abiotic pathway is found, what type of mission will confirm Venusian life? I imagine that everyone will agree it's way too dangerous to bring a sample back to Earth for analysis, so I expect we'll need to send microscopes to Venus. We'll also need to send something down into the appropriate cloud layer to collect a sample. Keeping anything aloft in the atmosphere will be expensive, so I assume that they'll separate those two elements of the mission, Apollo-style. So I expect that they'll send an orbiter containing the microscopes, and then a glider that collects the sample and then fires an engine to get out of the atmosphere and rendezvous with the orbiter (a helicopter would also be possible, but I expect it will be easier to get a plane back out of the atmosphere than to launch some kind of ascent vehicle from a helicopter). If they can design the sample capture mission to preserve the atmospheric pressure, temperature, etc. they might be able to get it up for analysis with the organisms still alive.



> I imagine that everyone will agree it's way too dangerous to bring a sample back to Earth for analysis

There’s always the ISS.


People come and go from the ISS, just as they do from labs on earth. Is the ISS really that different?


I mean, people come and go to labs holding _smallpox_. I would assume the main risk of bringing back to earth would be landing failure, but just having the thing in a room doesn't seem like a huge risk compared with what certain labs already deal with.


I'd argue that ISS is a bit too close for comfort to Earth to be analyzing extra terrestrial bacterial samples.

So a moon base or more realistically something orbiting Moon would be a better candidate.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: