Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Not sure where the 69 figure comes from. Top post has more info:

> As a back of the envelope calculation, if you covered the ~2.44 m2 roof of a VW ID3 with solar panels you'd probably see somewhere in the region of 244 kWh / year (based on typical UK solar panel generation per year - this would be more in a sunny place). At 4.3 miles/kWh that gives you just over 1000 miles / year of self charged driving.

The 4.3 is pretty optimistic, most cars are rated around 3 miles per kwh, but I digress. Optimistically it'd mean 1000 miles per year or 19 miles per week, or 2.7 miles per day.

I'd say firstly, this is already a niche category. The average car drives 30 miles a day, or more than 10x what this would charge under optimistic mileage.

Second, the extra weight would likely make this comparison even worse.

Third, not really cost-efficient, either, to install a complete solar system for every 2.5 metres. Much of the cost isn't in the panels but in the system around it.

Fourth, I doubt even the 69 mile a week category of people will still mostly have personal cars within 5-10 years. The flexible car rental market is taking off. In Amsterdam for example there's now about 100 thousand users of Sharenow alone, one of the multiple car rental providers, on a population of about 800 thousand people. Anyone who drives 69 miles a week or 10 miles a day, is typically better off renting. At a speed of 20 miles per hour you're looking at 30 minutes or 6 euros per day for your complete car usage costs, i.e. 180 a month. That's less than most cars (300-400 a month) cost in insurance, deprecation, taxes, fuel and parking in Europe. These companies are expanding sufficiently to allow most people in this low-usage group to do away with a personal car within 5 years I think. By the time these solarpanel cars could even start coming online, it's likely that most cars will have increased usage rates and that these solar panels won't even power a few percent of the mileage.



The average miles per day does not matter. It does not need to be usefull to everybody before it is useful to anybody.

What matters is the lowest 25% percentile. Getting 25% of the market is enough.


The market for people who drive less than 100 miles/week isn't a good target. You have way to much completion from existing stock. There are tons of $10k or less cars out there that will always be a better option than the sticker price of this car.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: