Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I have no issues with religious people. I do however have issues with "missionary" types popping up around people who are vulnerable, trying to convince them with completely baseless claims of wellness.



Considering the vast majority of people who have overcome addictions with the help of religion and a religious community, "completely baseless claims of wellness" is pretty exaggerated no?


Any citation on the vast majority of people who have overcome convictions have done it with religion? I don't think court ordered AA really counts.


This seems pretty interesting https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6759672/ . I didn't read the full paper, but based off the introduction it seems to be a study of how religion helps people overcome addition.


The study was done by someone from the Institute for Studies of Religion. I am not convinced.


My comment was in no way missionary. In fact I didn’t even mention one specific religion and suggested that you investigate your ancestors instead and find your path.


Do you have a problem with secular psychologists offering help to people in need?

People that have gone through horrible circumstances can, and often do, benefit greatly from the moral certainty that religion provides.


Which morality is that?

Individuals love to look at individual bits of morality in said books in a choose your own adventure exploration. As much as the moral certainty says be nice to others, it will also contain many bits that are highly questionable and would deeply conflict with others views.

In general secular psychologists don't come with the violent historical baggage that religions do.


>Which morality is that?

Who cares? It gets drug addicts clean and criminals reformed.


And turns them in to extremists that attack and kill others? It turns out there are many cares in which system of morality one chooses.


>And turns them in to extremists that attack and kill others?

I'd be curious to see the stats on that.


Secular psychologists don't ask you to believe in deities for them to work


There is no more moral certainty in religion than on the Sunday paper.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: