Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> We should celebrate this full spectrum narrative control, not 'investigate' it.

Ignoring any moral qualms or suspicions, any powerful weapon that isn’t actively overseen will inevitably be abused.



who watchers the watchers though, this is infinitive regress. Besides, who or what is being abused, and what qualifies as such, as also part of the program


> who watchers the watchers though, this is infinitive regress.

Infinite regress is only contemplated when you aim for perfect oversight which is impossible. The best we can hope for is 'as good as possible'. We the People, as well as possible, oversee that the appropriate authorities are, independently as possible, overseeing the use of weapons and interventions. It's obviously imperfect just like any other human endeavor but that's why we as citizens should fight for strong whistleblower protections, regular investigations/audits and reasonable timeframes for declassification etc so that we can do our job.


>who watchers the watchers though

We all should - one of many arguments for complete transparency. Democracy dies behind closed doors. All the claims about the need for government secrecy, "national security", protecting "methods and sources" are trash when compared against the importance of transparency in a society purportedly governed by elected representatives of the people. The so-called "risks" posed by radical and complete government transparency are far less than the actual and tangible harms caused by the ever-growing secrecy afforded and demanded by those holding the levers of power.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: