Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I don't follow. Did you accidentally reply to the wrong comment?



No, why? The point was EEs and MEs, or rather traditional engineering heavy culture produces bad software (never mind the first software devs tended to be EEs), so Juicero is good example of a software-leaning culture producing shitty hardware products.


Uh, the Juicero was spectacular hardware. The mechanical engineering in that beast was absolutely beautiful.

I don't recall what the software was like, but none of that is why it failed, it was simply a moronic business idea. An overpriced subscription for low quality fruit in a DRM-laden pouch. Nobody wanted it then or now.


The Juicero was terrible hardware in the sense that they could have made a product that was functionally similar but cost far less to make. It seems like they got a hardware engineering team straight out of college and gave them no constraints or budget. You have a giant CNC'd aluminum frame, a custom gearbox, a custom power supply, a custom drive motor, etc. All of this is only necessary because they decided to squeeze the juice out of the bags by applying thousands of pounds of force to the entire surface of the bag at once vs. using a roller or something. They were likely losing hundreds of dollars per unit even when they were selling the press for $600.


Squeezing the entire bag was the selling point. It's not negotiable. The important question is how much money they could have saved without changing that aspect.


I kinda want a Juicero now, but only as an object d'Art. It was a garbage product.




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: