I think there's definitely a qualitative difference, though. Salad fingers, at least, had better quality "stories", and the weirdness was less "basic." Skibidi Toilet is an excellent representation of the hyper-ADHD-ification of kids due to rapid-fire content consumption brought on by newer social media platforms.

I'm a bit younger than the average commenter here, but not young enough to be in the "skibidi toilet" demographic. But looking at both skibidi and the older type of YTP and idk the talking orange videos for example, I just don't see the difference. Maybe it's because I was too young to grow up watching them a lot but yeah. And that's saying nothing of the much more ADHD type of videos that were also common back then.

Yeah, a better comparison would be between Salad Fingers and something like Don't Hug Me I'm Scared or Local 58.

Tbh this kind of sounds like that old man saying music in the 80s was the best and it’s never been good since.

And this sounds like a convenient way to dismiss criticism/comparisons of new vs old. Not every such thing is an old man raging at change he doesn't understand. Sometimes there actually is some merit to the criticism.

I never wrote or implied that Skibidi Toilet doesn't have a plot or themes.

I never wrote or implied you did.

But is that old man wrong?

That's both sexist and ageist. Old men's opinions are deserving of consideration as any other.

You sure about that?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EIyixC9NsLI

This is the era terms like "lolrandom" were invented for.

https://knowyourmeme.com/memes/im-so-random-lol-so-random-so...

See also: ROFLcopter, AEIOUAEIOUAEIOUAEIOUAEIOU, making funny noises with text to speech.

Why did you have to mention ADHD? It has nothing to do with ADHD... As someone honestly struggling with severe ADHD for years, it's as if you told a disabled person that the latest new movie is not a great watch because it makes whoever watches it disabled.

Meanwhile, 11 years ago...

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dzMq5_thk4o

Really? I think it's pretty smart and funny, despite being in my 50s. Y'all need more Ma-Ma-Max Headroom in your lives.

I was there for Max Headroom. Wasn’t impressed by it.

> had better quality "stories", and the weirdness was less "basic.

I don't think the basicness is unintentional. It's like it's making fun of action movies for being excessively loud and violent

I’ve watched all of the skibidi toilet episodes. It’s really the same as 2000s or 2010s gmod YouTube poop, it just managed to find a larger audience.

Badger Badger Badger

Mushroom Mushroom

arggg, a snake, it's a snake!

asdfmovie is from, like, 2010

Okay but there is absolutely NOTHING wrong with Homestar Runner. Well... yes there is, but there's nothing wrong with the site aside from it being built in Flash.

I remember them making a metajoke[1] about Flash being dead and Strongbad was trying to rapidly learn HTML5 as a result lol

1. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L0nuQ5o2DYU

There is a Poopsmith.

I have to assume that us quoting Strongbad seemed as weird to our parents as this skibidi toilet or whatever is gem these days.

Honestly I would have struggled to describe to my parents why on earth I was howling with laughter when "homsar" became a thing on Homestar Runner. I'm quite happy that Gen Z have their own weird humour like skibidi toilet that is impenetrable for older people like me.

There's even a level that I can genuinely enjoy this little universe too - I have no idea if these tweets and replies are made by someone invested in the whole toilet thing or poking fun at it (likely the latter) but I loved them: https://twitter.com/nleglopnar/status/1679676790401380357

20 years old. Not an iPad kid. It might just be shitposting in the end but I watched around a half hour of it a few weeks ago and I found the sci-fi war story interesting, the occasional moments of "humanity" touching, the action impressive, and yes, the toilet humor funny. All the more impressive with effectively no dialog.

No Happy Tree Friends?

Thanks for writing that; my kid told me about skibidi toilet yesterday and I wasn't parsing "skibidi" well enough to look it up.

Sick Animation is still around and even dumber and better than ever.

If anything, I had a feeling of pride and nostalgia with Skibidi Toilet. It's a long and proud tradition of total nonsense somehow turning out to be funny.

What's different today is that it's actually popular. Whereas none of the other kids at school knew about Neil Cicierega or Arfenhouse.

The badger song is pretty random