Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

My time on Wall Street has actually made me quite averse to the whole broad shareholding/democratised finance movement. The fact that 90% of finance related posts' comments on HackerNews, a top quartile intelligence population, make me cringe tells me we should restrict market access to institutions and accredited (read: very liquid) investors.



Yea! Because people are stoopid! Stoopid people shouldn't vote!


All these suckers invested in Facebook, prices fell, and now they're bitching about how there was inside information that they didn't know about, that would have prevented them from investing in the first place. Tough shit. That's life, and this sort of thing will happen. What's NOT ok is to sue (http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/05/23/us-nasdaq-facebook...) over the loss of money, due to you investing in a business you don't know anything about.

I just can't understand why this is okay. My brain hurts.


I don't understand many shareholder lawsuits. Especially when the lawsuits are robo-generated, eg once a stock's value crosses a threshold. It seems like unnecessary, unproductive overhead. Like anyone is guaranteed a profit.

As for Facebook, I'm ambivalent. Kinda like the housing bubble. Everyone with have a twit knew that prices were inflated. Most all the players were bad actors. And the people who choose to gamble, well, tough noogies.

But what I do get worked up about is fraud. If Facebook lied, like the mortgage brokers, lenders, foreclosure goons, etc, as in made false statements in their filings, equivalent to committing purjury, then throw that book at them. That's contract law. There's no way for an open market to function well if the players are allowed to lie about legal statements.

(Not that I think Facebook lied. Nor do I care; I'm not an investor. I'm just kinda amused that so many people were fleeced.)

(My snarky response about voters being stoopid is more about the undemocratic impulses of libertarian fruitcakes. People given high quality information make high quality decisions. The remedy for bad decisions is education and patience, not yanking people's rights.)




Consider applying for YC's Spring batch! Applications are open till Feb 11.

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: