Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

[flagged]



I actually think indoctrinating their children in western human liberalism -is- a feature. But whether it’s a feature or a flaw, it’s an aspect of having the best brand on earth that those with the most money aspire to it. If you’re in an African country Harvard degrees are extremely prestigious, more so than in America, so the drive to attain it is even greater - even if it’s largely limited to the wealthy. But not entirely - Harvard is need blind and pays 100% of the way for many international students. You are either there because you’re exceptional or exceptionally rich.

> You are either there because you’re exceptional or exceptionally rich.

Or a certain skin color known for their personality... https://www.nytimes.com/2018/06/15/us/harvard-universities-p...


The culture that prevails at Harvard isn’t Americanism. It’s elitist managerialism and liberal internationalism. It’s an ideology that children of foreign elites can easily assimilate into, because they come from cultures where better people rule over “the masses.” (Remember, aristocrats think that their status is a kind of meritocracy.) Actual Brahmins assimilate easily into Boston Brahminism.

What defines Americanism is a quote I love attributed to Bill Buckley:

> I would rather be governed by the first 2000 people in the Boston telephone directory than by the 2000 people on the faculty of Harvard University.

Remember that Buckley was as close as it gets to being an american aristocrat. But the sentiment reflects an american tradition where people in elite positions are expected to, at least outwardly, express embarrassment or skepticism about their own status. America a country of yeoman farmers.


> I would rather be governed by the first 2000 people in the Boston telephone directory than by the 2000 people on the faculty of Harvard University.

Changing my last name to Aaaaaaaaaaaa now.


FONZIE!

By that logic slavery should have been abolished by the reeducated elite in the middle east years ago. The education does nothing but provide connections.

Wait what? Outside of ISIS and groups like that there is no slavery legal in any country. Kafala isn’t actually slavery, despite its abuses. And middle eastern countries have become substantial more liberal humanist during the last 50 years which is assuredly a result of cultural exchange. King Abdullah II in Jordan, Malik Dalan, Osama El-Baz, etc the list of active reformers that are Harvard alum and power brokers in Arabic counties is long. Longer still are the people who don’t get headlines for liberal reform but push the society leftward year over year. Even hard core counties like Saudi Arabia are significantly more open and liberal than they were 50 years ago.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Slavery_in_Libya

not really up to date with reality are we? there are tons of "permanently employed illegals" with dubious chances of payment . Half the fighting done in libya, sudan, yemen is done by refugees pressured into service.


That makes no sense. In what way is all well-off families in South Korea or Japan evil?

Nobody said “evil.” But do you think it’s a good thing for ordinary americans to have the children of chaebols owners rubbing shoulders with the children of Fortune 500s CEOs?

…Yes? This is the foundational concept underlying free speech and liberal education.

In a liberal society ideas live and die by their merits and we all benefit by the best ideas floating to the top.


I don’t think there’s anything “liberal” about facilitating the a borderless global elite. People can say whatever they want; Americans don’t need to issue everyone visas to come say things in person. The internet exists.

Is it better that the child of a despot learns at home or in the United States where ideas rule all?

IIRC Osama Bin Ladin was radicalized in the USA. Not every freely floating idea is great.

I can find no evidence that Osama Bin Laden was radicalized in the USA. When and how do you believe that happened?

Better for Americans, right?



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: