Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> Game theory is inevitable. Because game theory is just math, the study of how independent actors react to incentives.

That's not how mathematics works. "it's just math therefore it's a true theory of everything" is silly.

We cannot forget that mathematics is all about models, models which, by definition, do not account for even remotely close to all the information involved in predicting what will actually occur in reality. Game Theory is a theory about a particular class of mathematical structures. You cannot reduce all of existence to just this class of structures, and if you think you can, you'd better be ready to write a thesis on it.

Couple that with the inherent unpredictability of human beings, and I'm sorry but your Laplacean dreams will be crushed.

The idea that "it's math so it's inevitable" is a fallacy. Even if you are a hardcore mathematical Platonist you should still recognize that mathematics is a kind of incomplete picture of the real, not its essence.

In fact, the various incompleteness theorems illustrate directly, in Mathematic's own terms, that the idea that a mathematical perspective or any logical system could perfectly account for all of reality is doomed from the start.





Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: