Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

> It's actually impossible to delete the snapshot as a single operation, first you have to 'Restore' it. Oh the irony.

Now that's a bug! DO staff, fix this!

> so you're still vulnerable to your instance contents potentially showing up down the road when a hard drive ends up in a dumpster somewhere

From my experience in the computer refurbishing industry, any US corporation with a legal department has data-disposal-related asset-liquidation procedures. If the company is sensible, this results in giant magnets or DBAN; more often, though, it just results in a concrete warehouse floor and a sledgehammer. Either way, client data isn't getting out of the building. (see the sibling comment at https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7499125 for more details.)

It's true that someone who hacked into DO's live snapshot servers could dump and examine the disks and possibly find your data[1]. But they could, equally easily, hack into DO's live compute servers and dump your keys from your VM's memory. Until we've got homeomorphic machine-emulation software, instance memory, not snapshots, are the weakest link in your security.

[1] If the user-provided-snapshot servers are themselves a cluster of DO droplets--running, say, OpenStack Swift--then those instances would certainly get secure-erased. This is probably the way I'd set up the system myself, though I have no idea whether DO does.



Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: